but she's a girl...

Hitchiker’s Guide to the Galaxy

I've had Hitchiker's Guide to the Galaxy (H2G2) on my list at Lovefilm for quite a while, and have been simultaneously looking forward to and dreading its arrival. I've heard some people rave (in a good way) about it, and others hate it, so I wasn't quite sure what I was going to make of it. I watched it this weekend¹ and you'll know which camp I fall into when I say that I'm still thinking to myself, "...and another thing I hated about it was...". I don't think I've seen a film that I've disliked so much in a long time.

I am, of course, a huge fan of the original BBC radio series, the book, the BBC TV series and the new Tertiary Phase radio recordings (featuring most of the cast of the original radio series). I think that I'd have to say that I preferred the book and the radio series, but the TV adaptation was also pretty good, despite mostly dire special effects. So the film had a lot to live up to, but I'm not pathologically averse to Hollywood adaptations of books---the Lord of the Rings trilogy being an excellent example of an adaptation made with skill and respect. I read the books (twice) before seeing the films, and of course there were bits that got left out or cut down that were regrettable, but on the whole, it kept very closely to the _spirit_ of the books, and provided a different but fully compatible experience of the story. So while I understand that some things must be cut for pacing and to fit within the different limitations of the feature film format, I don't buy the argument that it's impossible to render a book faithfully on film.

Warning: the rest contains spoilers

My first problem with the H2G2 film was the dialogue and jokes, or rather the fact that the best ones in the book were missing in action. It wasn't simply that they cut some out totally (I could understand that with time constraints), but they butchered the jokes, leaving only a bleeding stump to puzzle those who aren't familiar with the book/radio/TV series and infuriate those who are. So, in the first few minutes of the film, when Arthur Dent is lying in front of a bulldozer, arguing with the foreman, Mr. Prosser, who is trying to demolish Arthur's house to make way for a bypass, we get this delicious bit of dialogue referring to the plans for the bypass:

Arthur: I eventually had to go down to the cellar to find them. Mr. Prosser: That's the Display Department. Arthur: With a torch. Mr. Prosser: The lights had probably gone. Arthur: So had the stairs. Mr. Prosser: But you found the plans, didn't you? Arthur: Oh yes, they were 'on display' in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying 'Beware of the leopard.'

That jewel of Douglas Adams' ability to heap absurdity upon absurdity---and which is quite important in character terms for introducing us to Arthur's mentality and his International standard ranting ability---was reduced to Arthur saying something like, "I had to go down to the cellar to find them". I could give many examples (like the Book's long discussion of the enormity of space being elided to "...etc."), but it would just depress me to Marvin-like levels. I wouldn't have minded these cuts if they made way for better material. But the film contains huge chunks of a rather pointless sub-plot that wasn't in the book in which Trillian is captured by the Vogons, and the others have to go to the planet 'Vogosphere' to rescue her. The only good bits in that whole section were Arthur's joke about queueing, the cameo appearance by the original Marvin from the TV series and Trillian's joke about the Point Of View gun. The rest? Mostly Pointless.

There was a lot of rather lame slapstick (the face-slapping thought mines on Vogosphere) rather than wit, and pointless action sequences instead of dialogue. I can't even bring myself to talk about the sappy love story that was soldered on to the plot, except to say that in the original(s), Arthur's main feelings about Zaphod stealing Trillian away from him seemed to be wounded pride, and if offered a choice between Trillian and a really good cup of tea, he probably would have chosen the latter. There were also problems with the casting (and acting). I thought that Martin Freeman was more or less OK as Arthur (though a little too likeable), Sam Rockwell was too manic as Zaphod (he should be a cool dude, or at least think he is), and Mos Def was just very flat as Ford. I've always thought that Ford should be a bit like a kid---enthusiastic, insatiably curious and with a rather cruel sense of humour. I didn't get any of that from Mos.

I hate being so negative about anything, but I'm really struggling to come up with even a few positive points from the film. Stephen Fry was very good as The Book (though shamefully under-used), Bill Bailey had a wonderful cameo as the whale (perfect casting), and Bill Nighy was excellent as Slartibartfast. Thank goodness that his line "...it scares the willies out of me" survived the Editor's guillotine. Some of the effects were very good (particularly the factory floor on Magrathea), but good effects don't make a good film. There was also some smart updating of one of the old jokes, when the Heart of Gold receives a recorded hologram² when visiting Magrathea:

It is most gratifying that your enthusiasm for our planet continues unabated. As a token of our appreciation, we hope you will enjoy the two thermonuclear missiles we've just sent to converge with your craft. To ensure ongoing quality of service, your death may be monitored for training purposes. Thank you.

But these few moments of enjoyment were very few and far between. I wonder what people who don't know the book/radio series/TV series made of it. It seemed to me that because big sections of original plot (along with explanations of why things were the way they were) were clumsily chopped out and replaced with bits of new plot which replaced the explanations with new non-sequiturs, they'd be pretty puzzled by what the hell was going on. And by removing the best jokes and dialogue, they did nothing to endear themselves to hardcore fans, either. If I could understand the decisions they made, I wouldn't mind so much. If I could see that they were trying to make more of an action film, or more of a plot-driven film set in the H2G2 universe, I might not like the results, but I could see why they'd done it. My problem is that I can't understand what the heck they thought they were trying to do.

¹ I say "I" because Mr. Bsag gave up after about 15 minutes. In the interests of journalistic integrity, misguided optimism and masochism, I stayed until the end. ↑

² In another nice cameo, the head and voice in the hologram was Simon Jones: Arthur Dent in the radio series and TV show. ↑