12 Dec 2005
When I got my new iMac G5, I also got an EyeTV for DTT. I saw these units being demonstrated at MacExpo, and was really impressed by the quality of the recordings, and by the tiny size of the box. We're constantly having problems trying to record the Freeview-only channels on our VCR, so it seemed like a great idea.
As I mentioned, the hardware box itself is tiny---about the size of a chunky box of matches---and is bus powered via the USB2 cable. There's a standard coaxial aerial socket on the back, and they provide you with a dinky little mobile indoor aerial. Since we don't have access to the aerial cable upstairs (and the roof aerial is pretty dreadful anyway---we have Telewest cable TV), we've been using this little aerial, and I've been amazed by the quality of the signal. The only problems we've had have been with the digital radio stations, which mostly seem fine, but then suddenly drop the signal altogether. Oddly, this doesn't seem to happen with the TV channels. I'm sure that this would be much improved if we got an amplified indoor aerial.
Setting the EyeTV up is very easy as it auto-tunes itself, finding a huge number of channels. You also get a year's subscription to the website tvtv.co.uk, which allows you to view TV schedules for all the channels and click a simple record button to set up a recording on your EyeTV box. The EyeTV box can check with the website every hour for new scheduled recordings, so it means that even if you're away from home, you can set up a recording as long as it's more than an hour or so before the programme starts. There's also a preference setting to allow you to tack a configurable number of minutes on to the beginning and end of the scheduled times, so that you don't miss any of the programme if the broadcaster's timing slips a bit.
Watching and pausing live TV is very simple, either with the menu options or hotkeys in the application itself, or with the included remote control. Full screen viewing is amazingly good on the 20" iMac---so much so, that we were tempted to move the iMac to the living room and ditch our rather old TV. If you are a single person household, that would be ideal, but when there are two or more of you, there might be some clashes when someone wants to watch TV and someone else wants to edit photographs or whatever.
Watching recorded programmes is equally easy. You just need to select the recording in the list and double-click to play. A lot of attention to detail seems to have gone into the EyeTV software and hardware, and another of the thoughtful features is that if you stop and close a recording part of the way through, it starts automatically at that point when you open it again. Joy of joys, you can edit recordings (to strip out superfluous stuff at the beginning and end, or to snip out adverts) and save the trimmed version. There are a myriad of different export formats available (including those suitable for the new video iPod or the Sony PSP), and if you have Toast 7, you can burn video to VCD or DVD in one step.
EyeTV is a pretty amazing piece of kit. I've been really impressed by the ease of setting up recordings, viewing, editing and exporting them, and by the quality of the video, even when using the tiny provided aerial. The only slight inconvenience at the moment is that we've got to either burn a DVD to watch a recording, or watch it up in the study, which isn't the most comfortable venue in the house. When our finances have recovered, we might think about getting an EyeHome, which would turn the iMac into a media centre, streaming TV, photographs and music to the living room. In the meantime, I might get a miniDVI to component-video adapter so that we can use my PowerBook to grab the content over the network and show it on the TV.
2
Jonathan Briggs: No we don't seem to have ever got that problem (unless we were trying to listen to a simultaneously broadcast concert on the radio while watching the visuals - digital TV and radio lags somewhat behind the analogue versions).
Nathan Ladd: I've been really impressed with it, as you probably gathered, but I'm guessing that you would need a different model in the US. From reading around, it certainly seems that the ones with no D-A conversion (or D-A conversion on the hardware itself) perform much better. This particular box just pipes an MPEG-2 stream straight to the computer, so it's not too taxing on the Mac hardware or software.
3
Now you need to work out how to get it working with Telewest. In my longer term plans I am thinking of getting a new Mac Mini (next years intel version) so I can play around with this sort of stuff. However I can not get terrestrial DTV (due to hills and the French) so I need to work out how to get Cable TV onto a mac.
4
Hi, We live in Tollard Royal and have Madge as our neighbour. Great eh! However, our TV reception is nil as we live in a valley with trees all around. We can not even use a mobile phone in the village. Would this system work for us? Many thanks Richard
by Richard @ 10/01/2006 8:01 pm • Permalink •
5
Richard: No, I'm afraid it wouldn't help you. It just gets its signal from an aerial, so if your Freeview reception is very bad through a roof aerial, it's not likely to be very much better through the EyeTV. It sounds like cable or satellite is the only solution for your location.
6
hi Richard in Tollard Royal, really happy to have found this bblog/website, We are thinking of moving to TR from salsibury and as it was a black hole for vodaphone and Orange, we did also wonder about TV reception esp as watch a lot of digital - is there any cable// - Which I doubt
by Sharlotte @ 17/05/2006 6:05 pm • Permalink •
1
Don't tell me, with your video recorder, you always found that the lip-sync was anything up to half a sentence out. Has your new gizmo solved this problem?----- Thanks for the great review. My desk is in my living room, along with my laptop and monitor. I have the 24" Dell display, and part of how I justified that display was by giving up a normal television: it's large enough to easily see movies on from across the room.
I've been eyeing these EyeTV things as a way to get regular television onto my Mac (and hence, my monitor) but this is the first good review I've read.
by Nathan Ladd @ 12/12/2005 9:13 pm • Permalink •